Disclaimer: We are reader supported. We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.
American Rare Coin & Bullion (ARC&B), based in Beaumont, Texas, operates at the intersection of two fast-moving markets: the numismatic rare coin space and the physical precious metals market.
Founded in 2008 as an inbound call center in Sour Lake, Texas, by owner and President Byronn Garrett, the company relocated and expanded into a full-service storefront on Eastex Freeway in 2021. It now serves collectors, first-time bullion buyers, and serious investors across the U.S., both in person and through its online shop at rarecoinpros.com.
With gold trading near $4,830 per ounce and silver sitting around $79–$81 per ounce in April 2026 up roughly 39% and 145% year-over-year respectively the timing of this review lands in one of the most active precious metals markets in decades.
Key Takeaways
- ARC&B holds a 4.9-star Google rating across 33 reviews and an A+ BBB accreditation, with documented buy prices of 95% spot on gold and 98.66% on silver.
- CEO and Chief Numismatist Trey Cox brings over 35 years of experience and has facilitated hundreds of millions of dollars in coin and bullion transactions.
- The company offers IRA-eligible gold, silver, and platinum products alongside rare numismatic coins a combination few regional dealers in Southeast Texas can match.
Before we get started with this review:
We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings. That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.
We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.
Look to see if the American Rare Coin & Bullion was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!
Or...
Get a FREE Gold Investing Packet from our #1 recommendation:
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Company Background and Market Position
ARC&B occupies a fairly distinct niche in the Southeast Texas market. Most coin shops in the region handle either bullion or collectibles, rarely both at a high level. ARC&B operates across that full spectrum.
Byronn Garrett founded the business with a focus on precious metals and customer education, and has over 20 years in the industry.
The Beaumont storefront, now at 3350 Eastex Freeway, expanded the company's reach beyond its original call-center model and positioned it as a walk-in destination for the greater East Texas corridor, including clients from Port Arthur, Orange, and surrounding communities.
Trey Cox, the company's CEO and Chief Numismatist, adds a layer of credentialing that goes beyond most regional dealers.
His 35-plus years in numismatics include work as a consulting contributor to several award-winning books on pre-1933 U.S. gold coins a narrow and technically demanding category that requires deep market and historical knowledge.
He developed ARC&B's Market Maker Program, which creates a structured two-way market for certain recommended rare coins, giving buyers a defined path to sell back their holdings. That kind of liquidity framework is rare at the dealer level.
Industry Memberships and Credentials
Credentials in the coin and bullion industry matter because the market has no centralized regulatory body. Buyers rely heavily on dealer reputation and third-party affiliations. ARC&B holds memberships with the following organizations:
- PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) — the largest third-party coin grading service in the U.S., used by dealers and collectors to certify coin authenticity and grade.
- NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) — the second major grading service, NGC-certified coins carry widely recognized market values.
- CAC (Certified Acceptance Corporation) — a secondary grading overlay that verifies PCGS/NGC coins as solid examples within their assigned grade, often commanding a price premium.
- ANA (American Numismatic Association) — the largest nonprofit numismatic organization in the world; ARC&B holds lifetime membership.
- BBB — accredited with an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
These affiliations confirm the company can handle grading questions, work with certified coins, and provide documentation that holds up to legal and fiduciary scrutiny. For estate liquidations or IRA rollovers, that kind of paper trail is not optional.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
The Local Market Context: Southeast Texas in a Bull Market
Southeast Texas has a working-class economy anchored in petrochemicals, refining, and maritime industries. It is also a region with a long history of physical asset ownership real estate, minerals, and increasingly, gold and silver.
That cultural disposition toward tangible assets has translated into a strong local market for bullion, particularly during the current run.
Gold hit roughly $4,830 per ounce in mid-April 2026, up about 39% year-over-year. Silver crossed its nominal all-time high of $121.67 per troy ounce in January 2026 and has settled into a volatile trading range in the $79–$82 range as of late April 2026, still up over 144% year-over-year.
That kind of price movement draws in both new buyers looking to enter the market and longtime holders looking to sell.
Numismatic News reported in February 2026 that the Florida United Numismatists convention in Orlando drew record crowds, and dealer observations noted roughly one in eight bullion-purchasing clients was converting into a rare coin buyer.
That pattern tracks with what ARC&B's market positioning anticipates: buyers who start with silver eagles or gold bars often develop interest in pre-1933 gold coins and certified rare dates once they understand the numismatic premium structure.
One Google reviewer from Port Arthur noted that after shopping multiple coin stores in the area, ARC&B's offer was unmatched.
Another reviewer confirmed the company was paying 95% of spot on gold and 98.66% on silver, with 100% spot on American Silver Eagles. Those are competitive numbers in a market where many regional dealers pay 85–90% of spot to sellers.
What ARC&B Sells
The product lineup covers three main categories:
Bullion
- American Gold Eagles (1 oz, 1/2 oz), priced around $5,990 and $2,960 respectively as of the time of this review
- 24k Gold Buffalos (1 oz), listed at approximately $5,992
- 1 oz Silver American Eagles (BU, 1986–2025), listed at $140
- 1 oz Platinum American Eagles (random year), priced around $1,375
- Walking Liberty Half Dollar rolls (20-coin), priced around $406.89
Rare and Numismatic Coins
- Morgan Silver Dollars (struck 1878–1921 at the U.S. Mint from Western silver)
- Pre-1933 U.S. gold coins, including Liberty Head Double Eagles (the 1890-CC $20 example on site is call-only pricing)
- 2025 Sacagawea 25th Anniversary Gold Dollar 24k, listed at $4,450
IRA-Eligible Precious Metals
ARC&B specifically markets IRA and 401(k) rollovers into precious metals. The IRA-eligible products on site include American Gold Eagles, Gold Buffalos, Silver Eagles, and Platinum Eagles all of which meet IRS purity standards for self-directed precious metals IRAs.
The company provides a Gold Guide and consultation process for buyers interested in this route.
Pricing Transparency and Buy/Sell Spread
One of the clearest signals of a reputable bullion dealer is how close to spot they buy and how competitive their sell premiums are.
Based on publicly documented Google reviews, ARC&B has offered sellers 95% of spot on gold, 98.66% on silver, and 100% spot on American Silver Eagles.
That is a tighter spread than many national online dealers, and substantially better than pawn shops or general antique dealers who may not track spot prices at all.
On the sell side, their listed price for a 1 oz Silver American Eagle at $140 represents a premium of roughly 76% over the April 2026 spot price of around $79.50.
That premium is on the higher end, though it is consistent with the broader market for government-minted coins, which carry collector value alongside their silver content.
Buyers who want the lowest cost-per-ounce typically gravitate toward bars and rounds, while those building a collection or preparing for IRA use tend to pay the coin premium willingly.
Customer Experience and Reviews
ARC&B carries a 4.9-star rating across 33 Google reviews as of April 2026. That is a small but consistently positive sample.
The pattern in the reviews is notable: multiple reviewers mention Trey Cox by name, describing him as knowledgeable, patient with first-time buyers, and willing to authenticate coins without pressuring a sale.
One reviewer brought in a collection of old bills, received an explanation of their value, and was made a fair offer. Another came in with concerns about coin authenticity, received verification, and ended up buying additional silver.
A reviewer with visible numismatic knowledge noted specific buy percentages (95% spot gold, 98.66% silver, 100% on ASEs) after visiting the new Eastex location the kind of detail that suggests the experience matched their informed expectations.
A long-term customer with two-plus years of transactions described consistent satisfaction across multiple purchases.
Customer service hours run Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM CST. The company is closed weekends. Phone consultations are available at 1-866-789-2646, and appointments can be scheduled through the website.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Shipping, Returns, and Operational Policies
| Policy Area | Details |
|---|---|
| Standard Shipping Timeframe | Within 15 business days |
| Carrier Selection | ARC&B chooses carrier based on weight and transaction amount; packages are insured |
| Return Window | 10 days from receipt for eligible items in original packaging |
| Restocking Fee | Up to 20% on numismatic returns |
| Non-Returnable Items | Bullion items, special orders, and trades |
| Coin Liquidation Payment | Processed within 10–15 business days unless otherwise specified in writing |
The 15-business-day shipping window is longer than some online-only dealers, but common among dealers who prioritize insured, carrier-controlled fulfillment for high-value shipments.
The 10-day return window is standard for the industry. The restocking fee on numismatic returns reflects the cost of re-certifying or re-listing coins that have left the store.
Who ARC&B Is Best Suited For
The business works best for a few specific buyer types. First-time precious metals buyers in the Beaumont, Port Arthur, and East Texas area benefit from the in-person education and authentication services there is no substitute for sitting across from someone who can look at a coin and tell you what it actually is.
Existing collectors looking for PCGS/NGC/CAC-certified coins will find a level of expertise that generic coin shops cannot provide. Investors exploring a precious metals IRA will find a streamlined consultation process and IRS-compliant product selection.
Buyers looking strictly for the lowest online premiums on silver bars or rounds may find better per-ounce pricing through high-volume online dealers. But those dealers do not offer authentication, in-person consultation, or the kind of two-way market that ARC&B's Market Maker Program provides for rare coin buyers.
Conclusion
American Rare Coin & Bullion is a legitimate, well-credentialed dealer that fills a clear gap in the Southeast Texas market, combining numismatic depth with competitive bullion pricing and IRA services under one roof.
For buyers in the region who want a human expert in the room rather than a website, ARC&B at 3350 Eastex Freeway, Beaumont, Texas, is the most qualified option available.