Disclaimer: We are reader supported. We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.
Stout Gold & Silver has been operating out of Amarillo, Texas since 1986, making it one of the longest-running precious metals dealers in the Texas Panhandle.
Run by Brett and Hannah Stout, the business is family-owned and physically located inside the vaults of Stout Safe Storage at 2300 SW 7th Ave.
That detail matters. For buyers in the tri-state area of Texas, New Mexico, and Oklahoma looking for a local dealer they can walk into, this is one of the few options with nearly four decades of continuous operation behind it.
Key Takeaways
- Stout Gold & Silver has served the Texas Panhandle since 1986 as a family-owned, in-person and online precious metals dealer with PCGS, NGC, ANA, BBB, and ICTA affiliations.
- The dealer carries gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in bullion and numismatic categories, alongside on-site secure storage and a buy/sell/trade service.
- Free shipping kicks in at $199.99, all shipments are fully insured, and each package requires a signature upon delivery.
Before we get started with this review:
We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings. That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.
We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.
Look to see if the Stout Gold and Silver was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!
Or...
Get a FREE Gold Investing Packet from our #1 recommendation:
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Who Is Stout Gold & Silver?
The shop opened its doors in 1986. At that point, gold was trading around $350 per troy ounce.
Fast-forward to today: gold closed out 2025 with an annual gain of roughly 65%, posting an average annual price of $3,435 per troy ounce, the strongest average gain since 1980, according to BullionVault. Silver's 2025 average topped $40 per troy ounce, a 41.4% jump.
Those numbers put context behind why interest in physical precious metals dealers has surged locally and nationally.
Stout operates within Amarillo's small but active precious metals community. The city has several dealers, but Stout's tenure sets it apart. Three generations of the family have been involved in the business, and the current owners, Brett and Hannah Stout, are the active faces of the operation.
The store holds memberships and affiliations with:
- PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service)
- NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company)
- ANA (American Numismatic Association)
- BBB (Better Business Bureau)
- ICTA (Industry Council for Tangible Assets)
For buyers evaluating whether to trust a dealer, these affiliations are meaningful. PCGS and NGC certification is the industry standard for graded coins. ICTA membership signals a dealer that participates in the regulatory and advocacy structure of the physical metals industry.
The Amarillo and Texas Panhandle Precious Metals Market
Amarillo sits in a region where agricultural wealth, oil exposure, and inflation sensitivity all run deep.
Panhandle investors tend to be conservative with capital allocation, and physical metals have historically been a preferred diversification vehicle here. Gold's performance over the last two years has amplified that interest significantly.
The World Gold Council reported that total global gold demand exceeded 5,000 metric tons in 2025 for the first time, with bar and coin buying reaching a 12-year high.
Central bank demand came in at 863 metric tons for the year, historically elevated. That backdrop drove retail interest at the local level too, and dealers like Stout saw corresponding traffic increases from investors looking to hold physical metal rather than ETF positions.
Texas has no sales tax on precious metals purchases, which matters when comparing a local dealer like Stout against online competitors.
Buyers in the Panhandle can transact in person with no additional tax burden, get same-day custody of their metals, and skip the wait associated with insured shipping. That's a tangible logistical advantage over national online-only platforms.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
What Stout Gold & Silver Sells
The inventory is broad. On the bullion side, the store covers four metals:
| Metal | Product Types Available |
|---|---|
| Gold | Coins, bars, rounds — from U.S., Australian, Austrian, British, Canadian, Chinese, Mexican, and South African mints |
| Silver | Coins, bars, rounds, hand-poured — from nine international mints plus secondary market options |
| Platinum | Coins, bars, rounds |
| Palladium | Coins, bars |
On the numismatic side, the catalog covers U.S. rare coins across most major series: half-cents, large cents, early American coinage, nickels, dimes, quarters, half dollars, silver and gold dollars, pre-1933 gold coins, commemoratives, colonials, territorials, patterns, and world coins.
There's also a bulk/common-date section for buyers looking to acquire coins by the lot.A themed bullion section rounds things out licensed products from Star Wars, DC Comics, Marvel, and Disney, plus general movie and TV character coins.
These are primarily 1oz silver rounds and coins struck by sovereign or private mints. They carry slightly higher premiums than generic bullion but appeal to a collector demographic that overlaps with the investment buyer market in predictable ways.
Buying and Selling Process
Stout operates as both a retailer and a buyer. The sell-to-us service covers bullion primarily, though the team will evaluate numismatic material as well. Walk-in transactions in Amarillo are available, which gives local sellers a same-day option no waiting on shipping timelines or insurance claims.
Online buyers go through a standard checkout process. Payment method determines how quickly a transaction clears. Once payment clears, in-stock items ship within one to three business days.
Delayed items are flagged during checkout with an estimated lead time. Manufacturer backlogs have historically ranged from a few days to 60 days depending on market conditions and mint production schedules.
The site also runs a deals section separately for bullion and numismatics, and a top items page that functions as a curated bestseller list.
Registered users get 24-hour advance notice on product availability alerts, which is useful during high-demand periods when secondary market coins or limited mintage products sell through quickly.
Shipping and Insurance
Free shipping applies to orders over $199.99. Carriers include UPS, USPS Priority or Express Mail, and FedEx. Ground or second-day air service is used depending on order value and weight. All shipments are fully insured from the moment they ship until the buyer signs for the package.
Every package requires a signature upon delivery. If a buyer has standing instructions with a carrier to leave packages unattended, the insurance coverage does not apply once that exception is triggered. Shipment problems must be reported within two business days of delivery.
If a package is lost or damaged in transit, Stout files the claim and pursues the insurance process. Claims typically take 60 to 90 days to resolve. In some cases, Stout may reship before the investigation concludes, at its discretion.
That's a reasonable policy for a dealer shipping high-value metals the key point is that the buyer is covered during transit regardless.
Bullion Storage
Stout offers on-site bullion storage through its connection to Stout Safe Storage, the same facility the business operates within. The storage setup positions itself around security, confidentiality, and accessibility.
Specific pricing for storage is not publicly listed on the website interested clients contact the team directly to discuss terms.
For buyers who want to accumulate physical metal without storing it at home, this is a local option that avoids the counterparty and logistical exposure of national third-party depositories. The vault is on-site, and the team is reachable at (806) 374-8698 or brett@stoutgold.co.
Pricing and Premiums
Stout prices its bullion products competitively against spot prices. The site displays products with an "as low as" pricing structure, which means premiums vary by quantity and payment method.
A check payment typically results in a lower premium than a credit card, as card processing fees are built into the price differential. This is standard practice across the bullion industry.
For buyers in the Panhandle comparing Stout against online-only dealers, the price-per-ounce calculation should account for shipping costs and insurance on those platforms.
On orders under the free shipping threshold at Stout, the shipping cost affects the effective premium. On larger purchases, the premium structure becomes more competitive.
Numismatic pricing is determined by grading, rarity, and current market demand for specific series these are not spot-linked in the same way bullion is, and buyers should come with some reference knowledge of PCGS and NGC population data and recent auction results for the specific coins they're considering.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Customer Experience
Verified customer reviews on the Stout website describe consistent themes: accurate product descriptions, careful packaging, and accessible staff. One verified buyer, Steven Holzworth, noted that he called ahead before his first online purchase and was walked through the process in detail.
Another, Adam Schaer, described the in-store experience with a team member named Brett as straightforward and honest on pricing. Ronald Cox, a customer who also uses the storage service, pointed to the owner's reliability as the primary reason for continued business.
A recurring note across reviews is the packaging quality. For silver coins in particular, transit damage is a real risk on thin cardboard holders, and buyers repeatedly flagged that items arrived undamaged and properly protected.
Who This Dealer Works Best For
Stout Gold & Silver covers a wide range of buyer types, but the fit is strongest in a few specific cases:
- Texas Panhandle and tri-state area buyers who want in-person transactions, same-day custody, and no shipping wait
- Investors building a physical bullion position in standard government-issued coins (American Eagles, Maple Leafs, Philharmonics, Kookaburras) who value a local relationship
- Numismatic collectors looking for PCGS and NGC certified U.S. coins across major series, supported by a team with multi-decade market experience
- Buyers who want on-site storage in a professional facility rather than storing metals at home
- Sellers in the Panhandle area with bullion or coin collections who want a local appraisal and same-day transaction
Online-only buyers comparing Stout against large national platforms will find competitive pricing on common bullion items, though the breadth of live inventory and the secondary market depth of a major online dealer will generally exceed what a regional shop can maintain.
The trade-off is personal service and a relationship with a team that has operated in this specific market for nearly 40 years.
Conclusion
Stout Gold & Silver is a well-established, credentialed dealer serving the Texas Panhandle with a consistent track record since 1986.
For regional buyers who prioritize in-person service, secure local storage, and a dealer with deep numismatic expertise alongside standard bullion inventory, it covers the relevant bases with reasonable pricing and a documented history of reliable transactions.